Elizabeth Wettlaufer: the case, the conviction and the sentence
A former Ontario nurse who used insulin to kill eight patients and harm six others between 2007 and 2016 pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison.
Crime Canada newsroomPublished
In short
Elizabeth Wettlaufer, a former registered nurse from Woodstock, Ontario, pleaded guilty in 2017 to eight counts of first-degree murder, four counts of attempted murder and two counts of aggravated assault. The offences involved insulin injections given to people in her care at long-term care homes, another care home and a private residence in southwestern Ontario between 2007 and 2016. On June 26, 2017, she received a life sentence in Woodstock, with parole eligibility only after 25 years. The case led the Ontario government to hold a public inquiry into the safety of residents in long-term care homes.
What happened
Wettlaufer was born in 1967 and grew up in Zorra Township, near Woodstock. She earned a degree in religious education counselling at London Baptist Bible College, then trained as a nurse at Conestoga College. In 2007 she was hired at Caressant Care, a long-term care home in Woodstock.
While working there, she began injecting residents with insulin. Seven residents of the home died as a result: James Silcox, 84, a Second World War veteran, in August 2007; Maurice "Moe" Granat, 84, in December 2007; Gladys Millard, 87, Helen Matheson, 95, and Mary Zurawinski, 96, in the fall of 2011; Helen Young, 90, in July 2013; and Maureen Pickering, 79, in March 2014. At the same home, she injected two other residents with the intent to kill them, and two elderly sisters whose later deaths were not attributed to her.
Charged or under investigation? Get a free consultation →
During her years at Caressant Care, she struggled with alcohol and drug use and was disciplined several times for medication errors, including suspensions. The home fired her on March 31, 2014, after a medication error that put a patient's life at risk; in April, it reported the dismissal to the College of Nurses of Ontario. Less than a month after losing that job, she was working at the Meadow Park nursing home in London, Ontario, where in August 2014 she killed Arpad Horvath, 75. She left Meadow Park in October 2014 to seek treatment for addiction. In later temporary and home-care work, she tried to kill a resident of a care home in Paris, Ontario, in September 2015, and a person in a private home in Ingersoll in August 2016.
The investigation and charges
The deaths had at first been considered natural. On September 16, 2016, Wettlaufer admitted herself to the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) in Toronto, where she told staff she had killed or tried to kill patients. CAMH alerted the Toronto Police Service and the College of Nurses of Ontario. Police said they received the information on September 29. The next day, she emailed the college to resign as a registered nurse, stating that she had deliberately harmed patients, called a college investigator to describe the 14 cases, and had CAMH fax a four-page handwritten confession.
Before her arrest, police obtained a peace bond on the grounds that she posed a risk of a serious personal injury offence. It barred her from having alcohol, insulin or other medications and from entering nursing homes, long-term care homes or retirement homes. After a two-hour interview with police, she was charged on October 25, 2016, with eight counts of first-degree murder in an investigation led by the Ontario Provincial Police. She appeared briefly in a Woodstock court and was remanded in custody. On January 13, 2017, after further investigation, she was also charged with four counts of attempted murder and two counts of aggravated assault.
Beginning in 2009, she had told a number of people about her crimes, among them friends, former partners and a pastor. She had also confided in a lawyer, who told her to keep the matter to herself. She was not reported to police.
The guilty plea
Wettlaufer chose to forgo a preliminary hearing and pleaded guilty to all 14 charges. In her statement to police, she said she knew the difference between right and wrong, that she had tried to stop and that the people she had confided in had not taken her seriously. She did not claim to have taken pleasure in the killings.
Sentence, appeals and parole
On June 26, 2017, the court in Woodstock imposed eight concurrent life sentences, with parole eligibility only after 25 years. She apologized. The sources do not report any appeal. She was first held at Grand Valley Institution for Women in Kitchener; in March 2018 she was moved to a secure facility in Montreal to receive medical treatment.
What the case changed
On the day of the sentencing, Attorney General Yasir Naqvi and Health Minister Eric Hoskins announced a public inquiry. The Public Inquiry into the Safety and Security of Residents in the Long-Term Care Homes System was formally created on August 1, 2017, with Justice Eileen Gillese of the Court of Appeal for Ontario as commissioner. About two years later, it issued three main findings and recommendations, including mandatory training for administrators and directors of nursing, better screening and background checks for new hires, less reliance on agency nurses, stronger reporting of critical incidents and changes to provincial regulations.
The College of Nurses of Ontario faced criticism for not restricting her licence after it learned of her 2014 dismissal. The college said it had lacked the legal power to restrict a nurse before completing an investigation until the provincial Protecting Patients Act became law in 2017. On July 25, 2017, a discipline panel convened by the college charged her with professional misconduct. She declined to take part in the hearing; the panel found her guilty and revoked her registration.
Timeline
- 2007: Wettlaufer is hired at Caressant Care in Woodstock; the first injections and the first two deaths occur that year.
- 2011 to 2014: Five more residents of Caressant Care die after insulin injections.
- March 31, 2014: Caressant Care fires her over a medication error.
- August 2014: Arpad Horvath dies at Meadow Park in London.
- September 2015: Attempted murder at a care home in Paris, Ontario.
- August 2016: Attempted murder at a private home in Ingersoll.
- September 16, 2016: She admits herself to CAMH in Toronto and discloses her actions.
- September 30, 2016: She resigns as a registered nurse.
- October 25, 2016: She is charged with eight counts of first-degree murder.
- January 13, 2017: Charges of attempted murder and aggravated assault are added.
- 2017: She pleads guilty to all 14 charges.
- June 26, 2017: Life sentence, with parole eligibility only after 25 years; a public inquiry is announced.
- July 25, 2017: A College of Nurses of Ontario discipline panel charges her with professional misconduct; the panel goes on to revoke her registration.
- August 1, 2017: The public inquiry is formally established.
- March 2018: She is transferred to a secure facility in Montreal for medical treatment.